prometheus

History

Bartlomiej Plotka a0df8a383a promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified (#7628 ) * promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified ## Changes * Refactored tests for better hints testing * Added various TODO in places to enhance. * Moved DefaultEvalInterval global to opts with func(rangeMillis int64) int64 function instead Motivation: At Thanos we would love to have better control over the subqueries step/interval. This is important to choose proper resolution. I think having proper step also does not harm for Prometheus and remote read users. Especially on stateless querier we do not know evaluation interval and in fact putting global can be wrong to assume for Prometheus even. I think ideally we could try to have at least 3 samples within the range, the same way Prometheus UI and Grafana assumes. Anyway this interfaces allows to decide on promQL user basis. Open question: Is taking parent interval a smart move? Motivation for removing global: I spent 1h fighting with: === RUN TestEvaluations TestEvaluations: promql_test.go:31: unexpected error: error evaluating query "absent_over_time(rate(nonexistant[5m])[5m:])" (line 687): unexpected error: runtime error: integer divide by zero --- FAIL: TestEvaluations (0.32s) FAIL At the end I found that this fails on most of the versions including this master if you run this test alone. If run together with many other tests it passes. This is due to SetDefaultEvaluationInterval(1 * time.Minute) in test that is ran before TestEvaluations. Thanks to globals (: Let's fix it by dropping this global. Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com> * Added issue links for TODOs. Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com> * Removed irrelevant changes. Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com>	4 years ago
..
prometheus	promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified (#7628 )	4 years ago
promtool	promtool range query should exit when fail to parse time (#7505 )	4 years ago

Bartlomiej Plotka a0df8a383a

promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified (#7628 )

* promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified

## Changes
* Refactored tests for better hints testing
* Added various TODO in places to enhance.
* Moved DefaultEvalInterval global to opts with func(rangeMillis int64) int64 function instead

Motivation: At Thanos we would love to have better control over the subqueries step/interval.
This is important to choose proper resolution. I think having proper step also does not harm for
Prometheus and remote read users. Especially on stateless querier we do not know evaluation interval
and in fact putting global can be wrong to assume for Prometheus even.

I think ideally we could try to have at least 3 samples within the range, the same
way Prometheus UI and Grafana assumes.

Anyway this interfaces allows to decide on promQL user basis.

Open question: Is taking parent interval a smart move?

Motivation for removing global: I spent 1h fighting with:


=== RUN   TestEvaluations
    TestEvaluations: promql_test.go:31: unexpected error: error evaluating query "absent_over_time(rate(nonexistant[5m])[5m:])" (line 687): unexpected error: runtime error: integer divide by zero
--- FAIL: TestEvaluations (0.32s)
FAIL

At the end I found that this fails on most of the versions including this master if you run this test alone. If run together with many
other tests it passes. This is due to SetDefaultEvaluationInterval(1 * time.Minute)
in test that is ran before TestEvaluations. Thanks to globals (:

Let's fix it by dropping this global.

Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com>

* Added issue links for TODOs.

Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com>

* Removed irrelevant changes.

Signed-off-by: Bartlomiej Plotka <bwplotka@gmail.com>

prometheus

promql: Removed global and add ability to have better interval for subqueries if not specified (#7628 )

promtool

promtool range query should exit when fail to parse time (#7505 )