This allows other processes to reuse just the remote write code without
having to use the remote read code as well. This will be used to create
a sidecar capable of sending remote write payloads.
Signed-off-by: Chris Marchbanks <csmarchbanks@gmail.com>
* Update remote write and remote read separately
* Add external labels to the remote write conf hash
* Add unit tests for remote storage lifecycle
Signed-off-by: Chris Marchbanks <csmarchbanks@gmail.com>
* Don't panic if we try to release a string that is not in the interner.
* Move seriesMtx locking in QueueManager's StoreSeries function.
This stops us from calling release for strings that aren't interned if
there's a race between reading a checkpoint and storing new series
labels, which could happen during checkpointing or reloading config.
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
* Unregister remote write queue manager specific metrics when stopping the
queue manager.
* Use DeleteLabelValues instead of Unregister to remove queue and watcher
related metrics when we stop them. Create those metrics in the structs
start functions rather than in their constructors because of the
ordering of creation, start, and stop in remote storage ApplyConfig.
* Add setMetrics function to WAL watcher so we can set
the watchers metrics in it's Start function, but not
have to call Start in some tests (causes data race).
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
From the documentation:
> The default HTTP client's Transport may not
> reuse HTTP/1.x "keep-alive" TCP connections if the Body is
> not read to completion and closed.
This effectively enable keep-alive for the fixed requests.
Signed-off-by: Romain Baugue <romain.baugue@elwinar.com>
* Fix ReadCheckpoint to ensure that it actually reads all the contents of
each segment in a checkpoint dir, or returns an error.
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
i) Uses the more idiomatic Wrap and Wrapf methods for creating nested errors.
ii) Fixes some incorrect usages of fmt.Errorf where the error messages don't have any formatting directives.
iii) Does away with the use of fmt package for errors in favour of pkg/errors
Signed-off-by: tariqibrahim <tariq181290@gmail.com>
a string when there are no longer any refs. Add tests for interning.
Co-authored-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
- Unmarshall external_labels config as labels.Labels, add tests.
- Convert some more uses of model.LabelSet to labels.Labels.
- Remove old relabel pkg (fixes#3647).
- Validate external label names.
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
* Consistently pre-lookup the metrics for a given queue in queue manager.
* Don't open the WAL (for writing) in the remote_write code.
* Add some more logging.
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
- Remove prometheus_remote_queue_last_send_timestamp_seconds metric. Its not particularly useful, we have highest_timestamp_seconds.
- Factor out maxGauage, a gauge that only increases.
- Change sharding calculations to use max samples in timestamp - max samples out timestamp (not rates).
- Also include the ratio of samples dropped to correctly predict number of pending samples.
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
- Add a dropped samples EWMA and use it in calculating desired shards.
- Update metric names and a log messages.
- Limit number of entries in the dedupe logging middleware to prevent potential OOM.
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
- If we're replaying the WAL to get series records, skip that segment when we hit corruptions.
- If we're tailing the WAL for samples, fail the watcher.
- When the watcher fails, restart from the latest checkpoint - and only send new samples by updating startTime.
- Tidy up log lines and error handling, don't return so many errors on quiting.
- Expect EOF when processing checkpoints.
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
- Tests that created a QueueManager were leaving behind files at the end of tests.
- WAL replaying (readToEnd)tests seem to require extra time to finish now.
- Some fixes to make staticcheck happy
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
* storage/remote: adapt tests for Travis CI
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Check filesystems on Travis environment
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Run remote/storage tests on CircleCI for troubleshooting
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Try using tmpfs partition
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Revert "Try using tmpfs partition"
This reverts commit 85a30deb72.
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Don't store labels in writeToMock
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Fix data race
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Bump retries to 100 meaning that the total timeout is 10s
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* clean up .travis.yml
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* code fixup
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Remove unneeded empty line
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
- Use the queue name in WAL watcher logging.
- Don't return from watch if the reader error was EOF.
- Fix sample timestamp check logic regarding what samples we send.
- Refactor so we don't need readToEnd/readSeriesRecords
- Fix wal_watcher tests since readToEnd no longer exists
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
- Remove datarace in the exported highest scrape timestamp.
- Backoff on enqueue should be per-sample - reset the result for each sample.
- Remove diffKeys, unused ctx and cancelfunc in WALWatcher, 'name' from writeTo interface, and pass it to constructor.
- Reorder functions in WALWatcher depth-first according to call graph.
- Fix vendor/modules.txt.
- Split out the various timer periods into consts at the top of the file.
- Move w.currentSegmentMetric.Set close to where we set the currentSegment.
- Combine r.Next() and isClosed(w.quit) into a single loop.
- Unnest some ifs in WALWatcher.watch, propagate erros in decodeRecord, add some new lines to make it easier to read.
- Reorganise checkpoint handling to reduce nesting and make it easier to follow.
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
This change switches the remote_write API to use the TSDB WAL. This should reduce memory usage and prevent sample loss when the remote end point is down.
We use the new LiveReader from TSDB to tail WAL segments. Logic for finding the tracking segment is included in this PR. The WAL is tailed once for each remote_write endpoint specified. Reading from the segment is based on a ticker rather than relying on fsnotify write events, which were found to be complicated and unreliable in early prototypes.
Enqueuing a sample for sending via remote_write can now block, to provide back pressure. Queues are still required to acheive parallelism and batching. We have updated the queue config based on new defaults for queue capacity and pending samples values - much smaller values are now possible. The remote_write resharding code has been updated to prevent deadlocks, and extra tests have been added for these cases.
As part of this change, we attempt to guarantee that samples are not lost; however this initial version doesn't guarantee this across Prometheus restarts or non-retryable errors from the remote end (eg 400s).
This changes also includes the following optimisations:
- only marshal the proto request once, not once per retry
- maintain a single copy of the labels for given series to reduce GC pressure
Other minor tweaks:
- only reshard if we've also successfully sent recently
- add pending samples, latest sent timestamp, WAL events processed metrics
Co-authored-by: Chris Marchbanks <csmarchbanks.com> (initial prototype)
Co-authored-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com> (sharding changes)
Signed-off-by: Callum Styan <callumstyan@gmail.com>
* *: use latest release of staticcheck
It also fixes a couple of things in the code flagged by the additional
checks.
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Use official release of staticcheck
Also run 'go list' before staticcheck to avoid failures when downloading packages.
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
Currently Prometheus requests show up with a UA of Go-http-client/1.1
which isn't super helpful. Though the X-Prometheus-Remote-* headers
exist they need to be explicitly configured when logging the request in
order to be able to deduce this is a request originating from
Prometheus. By setting the header we remove this ambiguity and make
default server logs just a bit more useful.
This also updates a few other places to consistently capitalize the 'P'
in the user agent, as well as ensure we set a UA to begin with.
Signed-off-by: Daniele Sluijters <daenney@users.noreply.github.com>
* *: remove use of golang.org/x/net/context
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* scrape: fix TestTargetScrapeScrapeCancel
Signed-off-by: Simon Pasquier <spasquie@redhat.com>
* Limit the number of samples remote read can return.
- Return 413 entity too large.
- Limit can be set be a flag. Allow 0 to mean no limit.
- Include limit in error message.
- Set default limit to 50M (* 16 bytes = 800MB).
Signed-off-by: Tom Wilkie <tom.wilkie@gmail.com>
There are many more (mostly finalizers like Close/Stop/etc.), but most of
the others seemed like one couldn't do much about them anyway.
Signed-off-by: Julius Volz <julius.volz@gmail.com>
* Add Start/End to SelectParams
* Make remote read use the new selectParams for start/end
This commit will continue sending the start/end time of the remote read
query as the overarching promql time and the specific range of data that
the query is intersted in receiving a response to is now part of the
ReadHints (upstream discussion in #4226).
* Remove unused vendored code
The genproto.sh script was updated, but the code wasn't regenerated.
This simply removes the vendored deps that are no longer part of the
codegen output.
Signed-off-by: Thomas Jackson <jacksontj.89@gmail.com>
This commit fixes a denial-of-service issue of the remote
read endpoint. It limits the size of the POST request body
to 32 MB such that clients cannot write arbitrary amounts
of data to the server memory.
Fixes#4238
Signed-off-by: Andreas Auernhammer <aead@mail.de>
More than one remote_write destination can be configured, in which
case it's essential to know which one each log message refers to.
Signed-off-by: Bryan Boreham <bjboreham@gmail.com>
This adds a parameter to the storage selection interface which allows
query engine(s) to pass information about the operations surrounding a
data selection.
This can for example be used by remote storage backends to infer the
correct downsampling aggregates that need to be provided.
* refactor: move targetGroup struct and CheckOverflow() to their own package
* refactor: move auth and security related structs to a utility package, fix import error in utility package
* refactor: Azure SD, remove SD struct from config
* refactor: DNS SD, remove SD struct from config into dns package
* refactor: ec2 SD, move SD struct from config into the ec2 package
* refactor: file SD, move SD struct from config to file discovery package
* refactor: gce, move SD struct from config to gce discovery package
* refactor: move HTTPClientConfig and URL into util/config, fix import error in httputil
* refactor: consul, move SD struct from config into consul discovery package
* refactor: marathon, move SD struct from config into marathon discovery package
* refactor: triton, move SD struct from config to triton discovery package, fix test
* refactor: zookeeper, move SD structs from config to zookeeper discovery package
* refactor: openstack, remove SD struct from config, move into openstack discovery package
* refactor: kubernetes, move SD struct from config into kubernetes discovery package
* refactor: notifier, use targetgroup package instead of config
* refactor: tests for file, marathon, triton SD - use targetgroup package instead of config.TargetGroup
* refactor: retrieval, use targetgroup package instead of config.TargetGroup
* refactor: storage, use config util package
* refactor: discovery manager, use targetgroup package instead of config.TargetGroup
* refactor: use HTTPClient and TLS config from configUtil instead of config
* refactor: tests, use targetgroup package instead of config.TargetGroup
* refactor: fix tagetgroup.Group pointers that were removed by mistake
* refactor: openstack, kubernetes: drop prefixes
* refactor: remove import aliases forced due to vscode bug
* refactor: move main SD struct out of config into discovery/config
* refactor: rename configUtil to config_util
* refactor: rename yamlUtil to yaml_config
* refactor: kubernetes, remove prefixes
* refactor: move the TargetGroup package to discovery/
* refactor: fix order of imports
For special remote read endpoints which have only data for specific
queries, it is desired to limit the number of queries sent to the
configured remote read endpoint to reduce latency and performance
overhead.
* Decouple remote client from ReadRecent feature.
* Separate remote read filter into a small, testable function.
* Use storage.Queryable interface to compose independent
functionalities.
The labelsets returned from remote read are mutated in higher levels
(like seriesFilter.Labels()) and since the concreteSeriesSet didn't
return a copy, the external mutation affected the labelset in the
concreteSeries itself. This resulted in bizarre bugs where local and
remote series would show with identical label sets in the UI, but not be
deduplicated, since internally, a series might come to look like:
{__name__="node_load5", instance="192.168.1.202:12090", job="node_exporter", node="odroid", node="odroid"}
(note the repetition of the last label)
staticcheck fails with:
storage/remote/read_test.go:199:27: do not pass a nil Context, even if a function permits it; pass context.TODO if you are unsure about which Context to use (SA1012)
Currently all read queries are simply pushed to remote read clients.
This is fine, except for remote storage for wich it unefficient and
make query slower even if remote read is unnecessary.
So we need instead to compare the oldest timestamp in primary/local
storage with the query range lower boundary. If the oldest timestamp
is older than the mint parameter, then there is no need for remote read.
This is an optionnal behavior per remote read client.
Signed-off-by: Thibault Chataigner <t.chataigner@criteo.com>
* Re-add contexts to storage.Storage.Querier()
These are needed when replacing the storage by a multi-tenant
implementation where the tenant is stored in the context.
The 1.x query interfaces already had contexts, but they got lost in 2.x.
* Convert promql.Engine to use native contexts
This can happen in the situation where the system scales up the number of shards massively (to deal with some backlog), then scales it down again as the number of samples sent during the time period is less than the number received.
Each remote write endpoint gets its own set of relabeling rules.
This is based on the (yet-to-be-merged)
https://github.com/prometheus/prometheus/pull/2419, which removes legacy
remote write implementations.
This removes legacy support for specific remote storage systems in favor
of only offering the generic remote write protocol. An example bridge
application that translates from the generic protocol to each of those
legacy backends is still provided at:
documentation/examples/remote_storage/remote_storage_bridge
See also https://github.com/prometheus/prometheus/issues/10
The next step in the plan is to re-add support for multiple remote
storages.
* Add config, HTTP Basic Auth and TLS support to the generic write path.
- Move generic write path configuration to the config file
- Factor out config.TLSConfig -> tlf.Config translation
- Support TLSConfig for generic remote storage
- Rename Run to Start, and make it non-blocking.
- Dedupe code in httputil for TLS config.
- Make remote queue metrics global.
My aim is to support the new grpc generic write path in Frankenstein. On the surface this seems easy - however I've hit a number of problems that make me think it might be better to not use grpc just yet.
The explanation of the problems requires a little background. At weave, traffic to frankenstein need to go through a couple of services first, for SSL and to be authenticated. So traffic goes:
internet -> frontend -> authfe -> frankenstein
- The frontend is Nginx, and adds/removes SSL. Its done this way for legacy reasons, so the certs can be managed in one place, although eventually we imagine we'll merge it with authfe. All traffic from frontend is sent to authfe.
- Authfe checks the auth tokens / cookie etc and then picks the service to forward the RPC to.
- Frankenstein accepts the reads and does the right thing with them.
First problem I hit was Nginx won't proxy http2 requests - it can accept them, but all calls downstream are http1 (see https://trac.nginx.org/nginx/ticket/923). This wasn't such a big deal, so it now looks like:
internet --(grpc/http2)--> frontend --(grpc/http1)--> authfe --(grpc/http1)--> frankenstein
Next problem was golang grpc server won't accept http1 requests (see https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/grpc-io/JnjCYGPMUms). It is possible to link a grpc server in with a normal go http mux, as long as the mux server is serving over SSL, as the golang http client & server won't do http2 over anything other than an SSL connection. This would require making all our service to service comms SSL. So I had a go a writing a grpc http1 server, and got pretty far. But is was a bit of a mess.
So finally I thought I'd make a separate grpc frontend for this, running in parallel with the frontend/authfe combo on a different port - and first up I'd need a grpc reverse proxy. Ideally we'd have some nice, generic reverse proxy that only knew about a map from service names -> downstream service, and didn't need to decode & re-encode every request as it went through. It seems like this can't be done with golang's grpc library - see https://github.com/mwitkow/grpc-proxy/issues/1.
And then I was surprised to find you can't do grpc from browsers! See http://www.grpc.io/faq/ - not important to us, but I'm starting to question why we decided to use grpc in the first place?
It would seem we could have most of the benefits of grpc with protos over HTTP, and this wouldn't preclude moving to grpc when its a bit more mature? In fact, the grcp FAQ even admits as much:
> Why is gRPC better than any binary blob over HTTP/2?
> This is largely what gRPC is on the wire.
By splitting the single queue into multiple queues and flushing each individual queue in serially (and all queues in parallel), we can guarantee to preserve the order of timestampsin samples sent to downstream systems.
- fold metric name into labels
- return initialization errors back to main
- add snappy compression
- better context handling
- pre-allocation of labels
- remove generic naming
- other cleanups
This uses a new proto format, with scope for multiple samples per
timeseries in future. This will allow users to pump samples out to
whatever they like without having to change the core Prometheus code.
There's also an example receiver to save users figuring out the
boilerplate themselves.
Specifically, the TestSpawnNotMoreThanMaxConcurrentSendsGoroutines was failing on a fresh checkout of master.
The test had a race condition -- it would only pass if one of the
spawned goroutines happened to very quickly pull a set of samples off an
internal queue.
This patch rewrites the test so that it deterministically waits until
all samples have been pulled off that queue. In case of errors, it also
now reports on the difference between what it expected and what it found.
I verified that, if the code under test is deliberately broken, the test
successfully reports on that.
Prometheus is Apache 2 licensed, and most source files have the
appropriate copyright license header, but some were missing it without
apparent reason. Correct that by adding it.
This gives up on the idea to communicate throuh the Append() call (by
either not returning as it is now or returning an error as
suggested/explored elsewhere). Here I have added a Throttled() call,
which has the advantage that it can be called before a whole _batch_
of Append()'s. Scrapes will happen completely or not at all. Same for
rule group evaluations. That's a highly desired behavior (as discussed
elsewhere). The code is even simpler now as the whole ingestion buffer
could be removed.
Logging of throttled mode has been streamlined and will create at most
one message per minute.
Allows to use graphite over tcp or udp. Metrics labels
and values are used to construct a valid Graphite path
in a way that will allow us to eventually read them back
and reconstruct the metrics.
For example, this metric:
model.Metric{
model.MetricNameLabel: "test:metric",
"testlabel": "test:value",
"testlabel2": "test:value",
)
Will become:
test:metric.testlabel=test:value.testlabel2=test:value
escape.go takes care of escaping values to match Graphite
character set, it basically uses percent-encoding as a fallback
wich will work pretty will in the graphite/grafana world.
The remote storage module also has an optional 'prefix' parameter
to prefix all metrics with a path (for example, 'prometheus.').
Graphite URLs are simply in the form tcp://host:port or
udp://host:port.
Because the InfluxDB client library currently pulls in multiple MBs of
unnecessary dependencies, I have modified and cut up the vendored
version to only pull in the few pieces that are actually needed.
On InfluxDB's side, this dependency issue is tracked in:
https://github.com/influxdb/influxdb/issues/3447
Hopefully, it will be resolved soon.
If a password is needed for InfluxDB, it may be supplied via the
INFLUXDB_PW environment variable.
Allow scrape_configs to have an optional proxy_url option which specifies
a proxy to be used for all connections to hosts in that config.
Internally this modifies the various client functions to take a *url.URL pointer
which currently must point to an HTTP proxy (but has been left open-ended to
allow the url format to be extended to support others, such as maybe SOCKS if
needed).
This change is conceptually very simple, although the diff is large. It
switches logging from "github.com/golang/glog" to
"github.com/prometheus/log", while not actually changing any log
messages. V(1)-style logging has been changed to be log.Debug*().
The one central sample ingestion channel has caused a variety of
trouble. This commit removes it. Targets and rule evaluation call an
Append method directly now. To incorporate multiple storage backends
(like OpenTSDB), storage.Tee forks the Append into two different
appenders.
Note that the tsdb queue manager had its own queue anyway. It was a
queue after a queue... Much queue, so overhead...
Targets have their own little buffer (implemented as a channel) to
avoid stalling during an http scrape. But a new scrape will only be
started once the old one is fully ingested.
The contraption of three pipelined ingesters was removed. A Target is
an ingester itself now. Despite more logic in Target, things should be
less confusing now.
Also, remove lint and vet warnings in ast.go.
- Move CONTRIBUTORS.md to the more common AUTHORS.
- Added the required NOTICE file.
- Changed "Prometheus Team" to "The Prometheus Authors".
- Reverted the erroneous changes to the Apache License.
- Always spell out the time unit (e.g. milliseconds instead of ms).
- Remove "_total" from the names of metrics that are not counters.
- Make use of the "Namespace" and "Subsystem" fields in the options.
- Removed the "capacity" facet from all metrics about channels/queues.
These are all fixed via command line flags and will never change
during the runtime of a process. Also, they should not be part of
the same metric family. I have added separate metrics for the
capacity of queues as convenience. (They will never change and are
only set once.)
- I left "metric_disk_latency_microseconds" unchanged, although that
metric measures the latency of the storage device, even if it is not
a spinning disk. "SSD" is read by many as "solid state disk", so
it's not too far off. (It should be "solid state drive", of course,
but "metric_drive_latency_microseconds" is probably confusing.)
- Brian suggested to not mix "failure" and "success" outcome in the
same metric family (distinguished by labels). For now, I left it as
it is. We are touching some bigger issue here, especially as other
parts in the Prometheus ecosystem are following the same
principle. We still need to come to terms here and then change
things consistently everywhere.
Change-Id: If799458b450d18f78500f05990301c12525197d3
- Mostly docstring fixed/additions.
(Please review these carefully, since most of them were missing, I
had to guess them from an outsider's perspective. (Which on the
other hand proves how desperately required many of these docstrings
are.))
- Removed all uses of new(...) to meet our own style guide (draft).
- Fixed all other 'go vet' and 'golint' issues (except those that are
not fixable (i.e. caused by bugs in or by design of 'go vet' and
'golint')).
- Some trivial refactorings, like reorder functions, minor renames, ...
- Some slightly less trivial refactoring, mostly to reduce code
duplication by embedding types instead of writing many explicit
forwarders.
- Cleaned up the interface structure a bit. (Most significant probably
the removal of the View-like methods from MetricPersistenc. Now they
are only in View and not duplicated anymore.)
- Removed dead code. (Probably not all of it, but it's a first
step...)
- Fixed a leftover in storage/metric/end_to_end_test.go (that made
some parts of the code never execute (incidentally, those parts
were broken (and I fixed them, too))).
Change-Id: Ibcac069940d118a88f783314f5b4595dce6641d5
Prometheus needs long-term storage. Since we don't have enough resources
to build our own timeseries storage from scratch ontop of Riak,
Cassandra or a similar distributed datastore at the moment, we're
planning on using OpenTSDB as long-term storage for Prometheus. It's
data model is roughly compatible with that of Prometheus, with some
caveats.
As a first step, this adds write-only replication from Prometheus to
OpenTSDB, with the following things worth noting:
1)
I tried to keep the integration lightweight, meaning that anything
related to OpenTSDB is isolated to its own package and only main knows
about it (essentially it tees all samples to both the existing storage
and TSDB). It's not touching the existing TieredStorage at all to avoid
more complexity in that area. This might change in the future,
especially if we decide to implement a read path for OpenTSDB through
Prometheus as well.
2)
Backpressure while sending to OpenTSDB is handled by simply dropping
samples on the floor when the in-memory queue of samples destined for
OpenTSDB runs full. Prometheus also only attempts to send samples once,
rather than implementing a complex retry algorithm. Thus, replication to
OpenTSDB is best-effort for now. If needed, this may be extended in the
future.
3)
Samples are sent in batches of limited size to OpenTSDB. The optimal
batch size, timeout parameters, etc. may need to be adjusted in the
future.
4)
OpenTSDB has different rules for legal characters in tag (label) values.
While Prometheus allows any characters in label values, OpenTSDB limits
them to a to z, A to Z, 0 to 9, -, _, . and /. Currently any illegal
characters in Prometheus label values are simply replaced by an
underscore. Especially when integrating OpenTSDB with the read path in
Prometheus, we'll need to reconsider this: either we'll need to
introduce the same limitations for Prometheus labels or escape/encode
illegal characters in OpenTSDB in such a way that they are fully
decodable again when reading through Prometheus, so that corresponding
timeseries in both systems match in their labelsets.
Change-Id: I8394c9c55dbac3946a0fa497f566d5e6e2d600b5
Chris Marchbanks