diff --git a/documentation/prometheus-mixin/alerts.libsonnet b/documentation/prometheus-mixin/alerts.libsonnet
index d37b12b43..85bde6a02 100644
--- a/documentation/prometheus-mixin/alerts.libsonnet
+++ b/documentation/prometheus-mixin/alerts.libsonnet
@@ -267,9 +267,9 @@
             alert: 'PrometheusErrorSendingAlertsToAnyAlertmanager',
             expr: |||
               min without (alertmanager) (
-                rate(prometheus_notifications_errors_total{%(prometheusSelector)s}[5m])
+                rate(prometheus_notifications_errors_total{%(prometheusSelector)s,alertmanager!~`%(nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx)s`}[5m])
               /
-                rate(prometheus_notifications_sent_total{%(prometheusSelector)s}[5m])
+                rate(prometheus_notifications_sent_total{%(prometheusSelector)s,alertmanager!~`%(nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx)s`}[5m])
               )
               * 100
               > 3
@@ -289,9 +289,9 @@
             alert: 'PrometheusErrorSendingAlertsToAnyAlertmanager',
             expr: |||
               min by (%(prometheusHAGroupLabels)s) (
-                rate(prometheus_notifications_errors_total{%(prometheusSelector)s}[5m])
+                rate(prometheus_notifications_errors_total{%(prometheusSelector)s,alertmanager!~`%(nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx)s`}[5m])
               /
-                rate(prometheus_notifications_sent_total{%(prometheusSelector)s}[5m])
+                rate(prometheus_notifications_sent_total{%(prometheusSelector)s,alertmanager!~`%(nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx)s`}[5m])
               )
               * 100
               > 3
diff --git a/documentation/prometheus-mixin/config.libsonnet b/documentation/prometheus-mixin/config.libsonnet
index 5c4d0123d..6b0c2f9f1 100644
--- a/documentation/prometheus-mixin/config.libsonnet
+++ b/documentation/prometheus-mixin/config.libsonnet
@@ -27,5 +27,15 @@
     // HA group. All labels used here must also be present in
     // prometheusHAGroupLabels above.
     prometheusHAGroupName: '{{$labels.job}}',
+
+    // nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx can be used to mark Alertmanager
+    // instances that are not part of the Alertmanager cluster
+    // delivering production notifications. This is important for the
+    // PrometheusErrorSendingAlertsToAnyAlertmanager alert. Otherwise,
+    // a still working test or auditing instance could mask a full
+    // failure of all the production instances. The provided regular
+    // expression is matched against the `alertmanager` label.
+    // Example: @'http://test-alertmanager\..*'
+    nonNotifyingAlertmanagerRegEx: @'',
   },
 }